Dude, I Invented Friggin’ Visual Voicemail. Heard of It?
by John Paczkowski
Posted on December 3, 2007 at 3:01 PM PT
As lawsuits go, the timing couldn’t be more perfect. Klausner Technologies filed a $360 million patent-infringement suit against Apple Monday claiming iPhone’s Visual Voicemail, a signature feature of the device, violates a few Klausner patents (so much for those vaunted “200 iPhone patents”). This on the very day that IDG World Expo announced that Apple CEO Steve Jobs will deliver the keynote address at Macworld Conference & Expo 2008.
Surely a coincidence. But no doubt an uncomfortable one for Apple. Perish the thought of Jobs pitching a defeaturing of the iPhone during his Macworld keynote. … “We’ve designed something truly wonderful …. Aural Voicemail. Boom?” Best to sweep this one from the decks before January, yeah?
Anyway, Klausner–a patent holding outfit founded by Judah Klausner, who claims to have invented the PDA and electronic organizer–alleges the iPhone’s Visual Voicemail feature violates two of its patents (U.S. Patents 5,572,576 and 5,283,818) and demands $360 million in damages and future royalties. Sadly for Apple it may well get them. Klausner has won two previous infringement lawsuits over the same patents, wringing settlement agreements out of AOL and Vonage both in the past year.
And Apple once licensed some of the intellectual property at issue here for use in the Newton. Apple’s accountants are probably already working out the math on this one. As are AT&T, Comcast and eBay, which were all slapped with similar suits.
Comments
Mr. Paczkowski,
Posted by paul hayes at December 4th, 2007 at 7:14 amWhy is this a sad thing?
It’s the law.
Either we all play by the same rules and respect intellectual property or we don’t.
If you don’t like patent law, blame the game, not the player.
I believe it was Abe Lincoln who said that the two greatest American achievements were the Declaration of Independance and US Patent Law.